Manchester United executives are recommending Michael Carrick for the permanent managerial position following his successful caretaker spell, contrasting sharply with Liverpool owners Fenway Sports Group debating whether to sack underperforming head coach Arne Slot.
See the key visuals
Listen to this episode of the The AI-thletic:
Introduction
The 2025/26 Premier League season concludes with a striking divergence in the North West. Carrick stabilised Old Trafford after Ruben Amorim departed in January. Down the M62, Slot faces intense scrutiny after a severe regression from last year’s championship victory. We will evaluate the structural choices driving these opposing trajectories.
Quick summary
Will Michael Carrick get the Manchester United job?
Omar Berrada and Jason Wilcox are formally recommending the 44-year-old to Sir Jim Ratcliffe this week. His interim record convinced the INEOS hierarchy he represents the optimal long-term solution.
Why is Arne Slot under pressure at Liverpool?
FSG must decide his fate after a disastrous domestic campaign negated the goodwill from his 2024/25 title win. A heavily funded summer transfer window failed to prevent a steep slide down the league table.
What are Carrick’s key tactical changes?
The former midfielder installed a pragmatic double-pivot system that immediately reduced opposition transition opportunities. This structure allowed United to secure five wins in his first six fixtures.
1. The numerical case for Carrick at Old Trafford
Omar Berrada and Jason Wilcox have seen enough to endorse the 44-year-old. OptaJoe confirms that Michael Carrick is only the sixth manager (and the first English manager) to win 8 or more of his opening 9 home games in the Premier League, and the first manager since Antonio Conte in 2016-17 (who’s record was also 8/9)1.
A mid-block is a defensive structure where the team concedes high possession but compresses space in the middle third to force turnovers. Carrick used this setup to neutralise opponents who previously bypassed Amorim’s aggressive pressing structure. The squad responded to this shift with improved defensive metrics across the board.
“Chief executive Omar Berrada and director of football Jason Wilcox feel Carrick is the right man to lead United into next season, and are ready to make the proposal to Sir Jim Ratcliffe.”2
2. Liverpool’s expensive regression under Slot
Fenway Sports Group must evaluate a domestic campaign that fell far below expectations. A significant summer investment estimated at £450 million yielded negative returns on the pitch 3. Fans point to bloated contracts for ageing players disrupting squad harmony. A 4-0 defeat to Manchester City cost Slot his status as the Liverpool manager with the highest win rate.
While mainstream coverage focuses on individual player errors at Anfield, the underlying metric points to a systemic pressing failure. Slot’s midfield spacing widened significantly compared to the title-winning 2024/25 season. Opponents isolated the defensive line with basic vertical passes. The high line remained, but the pressure on the ball vanished.
3. Contrasting tactical frameworks
The divergent paths of these two clubs stem from their approaches to central midfield control. We can observe the differences in their application of positional play.
| Metric | Manchester United (Carrick) | Liverpool (Slot) |
|---|---|---|
| Defensive Structure | Compact mid-block | High-risk counter-press |
| Midfield Profile | Double-pivot protection | Stretched single pivot |
| Transition Approach | Measured build-up | Direct attacking patterns |
4. Addressing the Solskjaer comparison at United
Appointing a former player after a positive interim spell carries historical risk for United. Supporters naturally fear a repeat of the Ole Gunnar Solskjaer era. Carrick operates distinctly from his former colleague. He demands stricter positional discipline.
Where Solskjaer relied heavily on individual brilliance and rapid counter-attacks, Carrick implements sustainable possession structures. The current iteration of United looks less erratic. They control game states rather than reacting to them.
5. The impending boardroom decisions
Allowing a manager to enter the final year of a contract without an extension signals internal doubt. FSG rarely make reactionary sackings but face mounting pressure from the fanbase. Slot must convince the ownership he can rectify the structural flaws exposed this season.
Ratcliffe faces a much simpler choice. Confirming Carrick provides continuity heading into a crucial transfer window. The INEOS sporting structure clearly values the calm authority he brought to Carrington.
Frequently asked questions
Who could replace Arne Slot if he leaves?
Liverpool are reportedly scouting alternatives ahead of the summer window. Options remain speculative until FSG formally clarify Slot’s contractual status.
When will Manchester United announce their permanent manager?
Sir Jim Ratcliffe is expected to ratify the executive recommendation shortly. Official confirmation should arrive before the transfer window opens to stabilise recruitment plans.
Did Arne Slot win the Premier League?
Yes. Slot won the Premier League title with Liverpool in his debut 2024/25 season before suffering a severe drop in form during the current 2025/26 campaign.
Final thoughts
The managerial landscape in the North West demonstrates how rapidly footballing fortunes shift. Carrick maximised a flawed United squad through pragmatic tactical tweaks. He correctly diagnosed the vulnerabilities in Amorim’s system and applied a functional remedy. This earned him the backing of the INEOS sporting directors.
Slot struggled to integrate expensive additions into a championship-winning core. His inability to adjust the midfield spacing when the counter-press failed proved costly. The 2026 summer window dictates the next phase for both clubs. Manchester United appear ready to build around their former midfielder. Liverpool must decide if their Dutch coach is the man to lead their rebuild.
Discussion points to consider
1. Has Michael Carrick shown enough tactical variation to avoid the familiar trap of past caretaker managers at United?
2. Who is ultimately responsible for the collapse at Liverpool, the underperforming players on the pitch or Arne Slot’s system?
3. Should FSG prioritise financial stability or immediate managerial change to rescue the Liverpool project?
| Manager Profile | Club & Ownership | May 2026 Status | Core Tactical Identity | Strategic Hurdle |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Michael Carrick | Manchester United (INEOS) | Pending permanent appointment following Champions League qualification | Compact mid-block, double-pivot midfield protection, measured build-up | Establishing long-term recruitment stability without replicating the Solskjaer era |
| Arne Slot | Liverpool FC (Fenway Sports Group) | Job under threat due to severe league regression post-2024/25 title win | Aggressive counter-press, single pivot structure, wide midfield spacing | Integrating £450m summer investments while fixing structural defensive vulnerabilities |