Recorded during Viktor Gyokeres’s goal drought in December 2025, this episode asks whether Arsenal’s £55m striker was the wrong fit for Mikel Arteta’s possession game. We cover his Sporting blueprint, the service he got, his decoy value, the striker debate and how his season turned.
Listen to this episode
Key quotes
What did Mikel Arteta say about Viktor Gyokeres’s slow start?
“We need to understand him a little bit better in certain situations,” Arteta said in December, accepting that a striker will be judged on goals: “That is logical” (Sky Sports).
How did Arteta describe what Gyokeres brings to Arsenal?
“He brings so much to the team,” Arteta said in October, adding: “The way he presses the ball, holds the ball, it’s just phenomenal” (Opta Analyst).
What did Gyokeres say when he joined Arsenal?
“Now I want to prove myself for real and perform together with the team,” Gyokeres said (Sky Sports).
Chapters
- 0:00 A square peg in a round hole?
- 0:45 A costly conundrum
- 1:30 “The best I’ve ever seen play with our shirt”
- 2:23 How Amorim engineered his success
- 3:25 A vacuum behind the defence
- 4:34 A space predator, not a technician
- 5:26 One Sporting-style goal at Arsenal
- 6:17 What Gyokeres is not
- 7:05 Slow build-up and low blocks
- 8:00 Saka, Martinelli and the crowded channels
- 9:32 The criticism of Martin Odegaard
- 10:21 The ignored runs
- 11:19 Is the manager to blame?
- 12:04 Why Trossard and Eze suit him
- 12:51 Clearing the bowling lane
- 13:41 The goals tally
- 14:31 The decoy effect
- 15:28 Who benefits from his runs?
- 16:29 Arsenal’s results with and without him
- 17:17 A missed pre-season and injury
- 18:11 Gabriel Jesus, the facilitator
- 19:05 Jesus’s finishing and fitness
- 19:51 Kai Havertz, the hybrid
- 20:38 Mikel Merino, the dark horse
- 21:45 Must the player adapt?
- 22:33 Why he is not Roberto Firmino
- 23:18 The case for more risk
- 24:04 What the ignored runs look like
- 24:58 Was he Arteta’s first choice?
- 25:51 Sesko and Vlahovic
- 26:38 The Erling Haaland comparison
- 27:26 The case for patience
- 28:13 The Havertz precedent
- 29:33 Plan B or a sale?
- 30:21 Lautaro Martinez and other targets
- 31:10 Four strikers, four profiles
- 32:03 The right player in the wrong system
- 32:51 Is control the currency of success?
Why did Viktor Gyokeres struggle at Arsenal at first?
In our view, because Arsenal’s patient possession game gave him little of the space he thrived on at Sporting. Before the Everton game on 20 December 2025, he had failed to score in 11 of his 14 Premier League appearances, and his duel success had fallen from 50% in Portugal to 37% (Sky Sports). Sky Sports also found that he had less space to receive a pass than any other Premier League player, 3.14 metres on average, compared with 4.92 metres for Erling Haaland (Sky Sports). In the episode we explain why a striker built for straight-line runs into open space found low blocks so hard.
How did Gyokeres play at Sporting?
As a runner in transition. Arsenal signed him for a reported £55m, plus up to £8.5m in add-ons, after he scored 97 goals in 102 games over two seasons at Sporting, including 54 in 52 games in 2024/25 (Sky Sports). His 39 league goals that season were more than Kylian Mbappe’s 31, although he finished second to Mbappe in the European Golden Shoe, which weights goals by league (Al Jazeera). We discuss how Ruben Amorim’s system, with the wide forwards drifting inside, cleared a runway for his powerful, direct runs.
Was Gyokeres useful even when he was not scoring?
Yes, according to the data. By early January he had made 956 pressures, more than any Arsenal team-mate, and 86 runs into the opposition penalty area, a rate of 6.3 per 90 minutes bettered only by Liverpool’s Cody Gakpo among players with 1,000 league minutes (Opta Analyst). Mikel Arteta said in October: “The way he presses the ball, holds the ball, it’s just phenomenal” (Opta Analyst). In the episode we discuss the decoy argument, the debate over Arsenal’s results when he started and the criticism of Martin Odegaard and Bukayo Saka for ignoring his runs.
Who should have been Arsenal’s main striker?
That was the fans’ biggest argument, and we compare the four options: Gabriel Jesus the link-up player, Kai Havertz the hybrid many fans saw as the best fit, Mikel Merino the versatile alternative and Gyokeres the vertical runner. Sky Sports noted that Merino had led the line in Arsenal’s two best attacking displays, against Tottenham and Bayern Munich, and that Jesus’s return added to the pressure on Gyokeres (Sky Sports). We also look at claims that Arteta preferred Benjamin Sesko; Arsenal did explore a deal for Sesko before signing Gyokeres (Sky Sports).
Did Gyokeres prove the doubters wrong?
Largely, yes. His penalty at Everton on 20 December ended a five-match goal drought and sent Arsenal back to the top for Christmas (Premier League). By early May he had 21 goals in all competitions, 14 of them in the Premier League, and was the first Arsenal player since Alexis Sanchez in 2014/15 to score 20 or more in a debut season (Opta Analyst). Arsenal won the title on 19 May, ending a 22-year wait (Premier League). In our view, the fans who asked for patience were proved right.
Discussion points
- Should Arsenal have changed their style to suit Viktor Gyokeres, or was he right to adapt to Arteta’s system?
- Is a striker who presses and makes decoy runs worth his place when he is not scoring?
- Who was Arsenal’s best striker option in 2025/26: Gyokeres, Havertz, Jesus or Merino?
Full transcript
Read the full transcript
0:00 Okay, let’s unpack this. We are diving deep into, well, probably the most complex and, let’s be honest, strategically debated signing of the season in North London. It has to be. We’re talking about Arsenal’s new striker, Viktor Gyokeres. Exactly. And this is so much more than just a striker who’s struggling for goals. Oh, absolutely. It’s a brilliant case study in tactical philosophy meeting a player profile. Or well, maybe failing to meet it. We’ve gathered a whole load of fan sentiment, expert commentary, and we’re drawing really heavily on those who watched him just dominate in Portugal. And on the flip side, the Gunners supporters who are, it seems, locked in this kind of ideological warfare over how to get him playing. They really are.
0:45 And that’s our mission for this deep dive. We’re trying to solve the central puzzle facing the Emirates faithful. Is Viktor Gyokeres a square peg in a round hole? That is the question. We need to really dissect his true player profile, understand the kind of immovable nature of Mikel Arteta’s system, and figure out what this tactical misalignment actually means for Arsenal’s title hopes right now. Yeah, because this is a 60 million pound conundrum, isn’t it? It’s all wrapped up in one massive question mark. We’ve got to move beyond just the simple stats. We have to explore the deep, deep tactical reasons that have stopped a player who was, let’s not forget, Europe’s top goal scorer last season from doing it in the Premier League. And the story here really isn’t about whether he’s a good enough player, is it?
1:30 Not at all. It’s about whether the system he’s in even allows him to be good at what he does best. Right. So to understand the current struggles, we absolutely have to start in Portugal. We have to establish the blueprint for his success at Sporting CP. We have to. And the context we get from those Sporting fans is, well, it’s not just vital, it’s genuinely startling. Startling is the word. We have sources proclaiming Gyokeres was, and this is a quote, the best I’ve ever seen play with our shirt. I mean, that is just seismic praise, isn’t it? For a club with the history of Sporting. It’s massive. It is, but, and this is the crucial bit, that praise comes with a necessary, and to be honest, a brutal caveat about his initial limitations. When he first got to Lisbon, the sources are really clear on this. He had, and I quote, an awful first touch, zero build-up play, and a terrible presence in the box, at least in the traditional sense.
2:23 Wow. So when you hear that about a player who’s just come off a season bagging, what, 40-plus goals, you start to realise something. His success wasn’t down to technical finesse. Not at all. It was tactical engineering. That distinction, tactical engineering, over innate technical skill, that just feels like the key to this whole thing. So the question is, how did Ruben Amorim, the Sporting gaffer, how did he figure it out? It was a profound structural shift in the team. He essentially manufactured the perfect environment for Gyokeres. He did this by shifting the team’s wingers. They didn’t stay out wide on the touchline, they moved inward, they started functioning essentially as central attacking midfielders, you know, as CAMs. Okay so if they’re moving inside they’re not hugging the touchline, they’re not stretching the pitch horizontally like you know most traditional wingers do to create space for the fullbacks. Exactly they’re doing the opposite. They’re collapsing towards the centre. Which you’d think would congest everything.
3:25 You would, but what it actually did was create tactical congestion in the wide half spaces. It pulled the opposition’s full backs and defensive midfielders with them into those areas. And this is the crucial part. By moving into those zones, they vacated the deep central channel and most importantly, the space behind the opposition’s deepest central defender. They created a vacuum. A perfect vacuum of space and that vacuum became the hunting ground for Gyokeres. Right. His entire success, everything was based on being fed the ball into that specific newly manufactured space. And how he got there. The sources describe his runs as powerful and clunky. Yes. Clunky is such a great word for it. It emphasises that this is about raw, straight-line speed and kinetic force. It’s not about delicate footwork. He’s a battering ram. He is. Yeah. And his success was all about giving him the longest possible runway to build up a head of steam. That detail, the clunky runs, it’s so important because it just refutes this idea that he’s some sort of versatile technician. He’s not. He’s highly specialised.
4:34 He is. He needs defenders to be running backwards towards their own goal or maybe sideways. He’s not effective if they’re just standing still waiting for him. And this wasn’t just a flat track bully system, was it? It worked against the big teams. Oh, absolutely. It worked against their biggest rivals, Porto, Benfica, and it even worked against elite European teams like Manchester City. Wow. The Sporting style was described as playing very vertically. It was all about rapid forward progression. The sources compared it in its intent to, you know, the famous Klopp’s Liverpool transition football. So win the ball back and just go. Instantly. The first thought was never caution or keeping possession. It was to get the ball into that space for Gyokeres as fast as humanly possible. Okay. Now, when we contrast that high-speed vertical style with the reality of the Emirates?
5:26 Well, the source material offers a truly damning statistic. It’s quite something, isn’t it? There is only one known instance, one successful execution of this specific style we’ve just described. A single Gyokeres-type through ball and goal against Leeds. One. We are talking about a sample size of one when it comes to playing this 60 million pound striker to his established documented strengths. The contrast just couldn’t be any starker, could it? You have a player profile that was explicitly engineered for high-tempo transitions in open space. His whole career success in Portugal was built on it. And he’s received that service once. Pretty much once in a major league season. That just screams tactical neglect or, well, incompatibility. So let’s summarise what he’s not based on this Sporting perspective, because that feels critical for diagnosing the problem in Arsenal.
6:17 OK. First, he is definitively not a poacher. He doesn’t survive on scraps or little deflection goals inside the six-yard box. Second, he’s not a target man who can consistently hold up the ball with his back to goal against two Premier League centre-backs in a slow, patient build-up. And the third one is the big one for Arsenal. It is. He is not capable of involved build-up play, which means asking him to link the midfield and the attack to be that deep-lying number nine, it immediately exposes all of his weakest technical attributes. So at the end of the day he’s a space predator. That’s the perfect term for him, he’s a space predator. And if the system fails to generate that space, his flaws are magnified and his strengths are, well, they’re completely nullified. So let’s look at the operational environment at Arsenal then.
7:05 The fans, the sources, they all describe the default approach as slow, controlled, and deliberate. Very deliberate possession build up. And the sources state that because of this, Arsenal constantly face super low blocks. And that’s because, quite frankly, they’re seen as probably the best in the league at holding the ball. Exactly. But that control, that caution, that seems to be the first nail in the coffin for a player with Gyokeres’s profile. Because it just removes that runway you were talking about. It removes the vertical runway he needs, completely. When you’re facing a low block, the other team has already eliminated the space behind their defensive line. It’s gone. They’re compact, sitting deep, waiting for you. And if your entire team is instructed to just recycle possessions safely until a perfect high percentage pass emerges, well, you are starving a vertical striker of the very fuel he needs.
8:00 Which is risk and speed. Risk and rapid forward movement, yes. But surely even against low blocks a team can use quick combinations, one-twos, that sort of thing, to penetrate. Where does the systemic failure actually begin to break down his effectiveness? Well it’s like a domino effect. It cascades from the tactical structure itself and it really starts with the inverted wingers with Saka and Martinelli. Okay. The sources detail an issue here. Their priority is goal scoring first, rather than serving the central striker. Right. So finding Gyokeres is what, a secondary thought? It’s a secondary consideration at best because the team is built to have multiple goal threats from all across that front line. Let’s break down Saka’s role in that specifically because he is, you know, the primary creative force on that right hand side. Saka is often criticised by fans for frequently slowing the game down. I’ve seen that a lot. He gets the ball, he assesses his options and rather than playing that high risk, high reward through ball, he holds onto it. He waits. And this often ends with him being triple teamed because the defence has had all the time in the world to get back and reorganise. Exactly. But the key structural issue, the bigger problem, is that Saka tends to push into central spaces. He drifts into that right half space instead of holding the width and stretching the pitch. And when the wingers push central… They crowd the exact channels that Gyokeres needs to be open for his vertical runs. So the team’s collective desire to score is actually canceling out the main striker’s ability to run
9:32 into scoring positions. You’ve hit the nail on the head. It’s like a collective of false nines all surrounding a true number nine. They’re taking away his ball and his space. And speaking of central creators, the fan outcry aimed at Martin Odegaard [unclear] is particularly intense. The criticism of Odegaard is widespread, and it really sits at the heart of this whole frustration. He’s accused of repeatedly, and I mean repeatedly, ignoring Gyokeres’s great runs. Opting for the safe pass instead. Always the safe sideways pass. Fans are saying he plays too cautiously, he slows the game down, and he allows the opposition defence to completely reset. Which makes Gyokeres’s hard work totally useless. Completely. And there’s mention of this sort of infamous 10 minute compilation video that’s apparently been circulating among the fan base.
10:21 Oh, I’ve heard about this. It allegedly shows Gyokeres making maybe half a dozen perfect line-breaking runs in a single game. And just being ignored. Ignored by every key player. By Odegaard, by Saka, by Declan Rice, all in favour of a safe, sideways, or even a backward pass. Okay, hang on a minute. If the fans’ sources are saying that Gyokeres’s presence actually improves results, and we’ll get to the stats later, the eight wins and 10 games thing, but he’s scoring few goals and his runs are being ignored, doesn’t that fundamentally undermine the whole right player wrong system argument? Yeah, how so? Well, maybe he’s just a better system player than we’re giving credit for. Maybe he’s a brilliant decoy and the manager knows this and is using him that way. That is precisely the internal conflict within the fan base. That’s the debate. Because some fans do defend Odegaard and the gaffer. They argue that [unclear] is simply executing the philosophy he’s been given. They say the issue is systemic caution.
11:19 So it’s the team that needs to change, not the number 10. Exactly. The team needs to increase its quickness and its risk tolerance rather than just scapegoating the main creator. But the anecdotal evidence of those missed opportunities, it remains really compelling. One source cited a specific match against Wolves where Odegaard ignored a run that would have resulted in an easy, easy goal just to tap in. And he chose to play it back instead. Chose to play the ball back. So if the manager is instructing caution over conversion, then maybe Odegaard is just the messenger executing those orders. Let’s look at the glimmers of hope then, because there are some. The specific partnerships that seem to momentarily solve this tactical knot, the sources point to Trossard and Eze. Yeah, and this is a massive tactical tell.
12:04 Trossard and Eze are highlighted because they operate completely differently to Saka and Martinelli. How so? They don’t stretch the pitch as aggressively and crucially, they don’t crash into that central channel as quickly or as often. And that, paradoxically, leaves the space open. It leaves the necessary space for Gyokeres’s vertical runs. They are, simply put better suited to feed him balls. So let’s use a metaphor here. If Saka and Martinelli are like, like, Formula One cars that immediately just crash into the central space occupying it, then players like Trossard and Eze are more patient. They hold the ball up, they draw defenders towards them, and they wait for the gap to form. That’s a perfect way to put it. Think of it like clearing a bowling lane. Saka and Martinelli get the ball and they immediately dart towards the pins, right?
12:51 They occupy the space, force the centre backs to mark them tightly. Trossard on the other hand, he stands there holding the ball. He draws the defence out of position, makes them wait, and that is what creates the clear track and the angle for Gyokeres to exploit with his run. So they get the best out of him precisely because they are not focused on their own scoring runs into his preferred zones. Spot on. And this reverse engineering of the attack, it just suggests that Arsenal’s default system is actively detrimental to their 60 million pound investment. It speaks volumes, doesn’t it? That his best partners are the ones who disrupt the expected pattern of Arteta ball. It really does. If your standard first choice wingers are actively canceling out your main striker’s primary strength, then you have a strategic dilemma that goes way beyond simple player form.
13:41 Okay, so let’s move on to the performance data. Because at first glance, the goals tally is the immediate sticking point. It is four goals from 18 Premier League appearances, six in 19 overall. For a striker who is signed as a guaranteed goal provider, that output is pretty underwhelming. Especially if, as some fans sources allege, those goals are mostly against, quote, c**p teams. Mm. And the counter argument to that is swift. It’s that the Premier League is a different beast. Of course. Those powerful, clunky runs that worked so well in Portugal, they’re just not as effective against higher calibre Premier League centre-backs who are, you know, better positioned faster and more physical. The assertion is that he just doesn’t have the technical subtlety to navigate those tight spaces you get in this league.
14:31 And that argument is backed up by some specific match details. One source noted he reportedly didn’t dribble past a single player in a recent match against Wolves. Not one. Which indicates his inability to create space for himself through individual skill when he’s being tightly marked. If he can’t run into space and he can’t create space himself. He stalls. However, this is where we have to delve into the unseen impact. This is the cornerstone of the pro-Gyokeres defence. Okay. Fans acknowledge his massive positive defensive contribution, his tireless pressure from the front, but more importantly they view him as a decoy and gravitational target man. Gravitational target man. I like that. Explain that concept. Well it’s the critical insight we can’t just gloss over. The idea is that even if he isn’t scoring or even touching the ball, his mere reputation and his aggressive forward movement force central defenders to commit to him.
15:28 So he’s pulling them out of position? He’s pulling the opposition’s deepest centre back away from the zone. And that doesn’t benefit him on the score sheet, but it massively benefits the players around him. OK, so how does that actually translate onto the pitch? Who is specifically benefiting when Gyokeres is doing this decoy duty? That’s an excellent question. When Gyokeres is occupying two centre backs high up the pitch, it fundamentally changes the space available for Arsenal’s midfielders and inverted wingers. For instance, his gravitational pull ties up that deepest central defender, which in turn creates crucial passing lanes or little half spaces for Martin Odegaard to operate in. Or it might allow someone like Declan Rice to push higher up into more advanced midfield positions because the immediate danger of a counter-attack deep in their half is delayed. So he’s destabilising the opposition’s defensive shape just by running even if the ball never comes to him. Precisely. And this means his value has to be measured in systemic benefits and defensive disruption, not just an individual goal output.
16:29 Which makes this statistical debate that follows even more confusing and more subjective. It does, because we have these really conflicting views on team performance when he starts. Right, so let’s take argument one, the pro-Gyokeres perspective. Okay, so they suggest the team’s results are objectively better when he is in the side. They point to those first 10 games before his injury. Where Arsenal won eight, drew one, and lost one. And they conclude that his unseen contributions, the pressing, the decoy runs, that they translate directly into a more consistent winning team. But the anti-Gyokeres camp calls those statistics ridiculously skewed. Why? Because they argue you have to factor in the quality of the opposition. The anti-Gyokeres side maintains that the team faced much better opponents when he was absent or injured.
17:17 Okay. So while the pro camp points to dropped points against Sunderland, Chelsea and Villa during his absence, the opposition argues those points were dropped due to broader defensive injuries at the time. Forcing Rice to play deeper, which affects the whole balance of the midfield. Exactly. So for them, the raw goals tally against the so-called c**p teams remains their key metric of his individual failure. It’s an impossible argument to resolve without some really complex contextual data, isn’t it? But the core fact remains that he missed vital adaptation time. He did. And we have to acknowledge the non-tactical factors here. Fitness and adaptation. He arrived already struggling. He’d effectively gone on strike and refused to train or play for Sporting to force the move to Arsenal. Which immediately robbed him of a full preseason. You can’t just walk into a complex system like Arteta’s without that. You can’t and that lack of full fitness followed by a hamstring injury later in the season that clearly impacted his confidence.
18:11 I mean he was always playing catch-up. He wasn’t just integrating a new style of football. He was trying to do it from a severely underprepared physical baseline. Which in a league as demanding as the Premier League that’s a huge, huge disadvantage. It makes the adaptation curve feel almost vertical. Okay, let’s pivot to the striker hierarchy debate because Arsenal now has four really distinct options and the discussion over who is number one is, well, it’s highly divisive. Let’s start with Gabriel Jesus. Jesus is pretty much universally lauded for his technical ability, his dynamic attacks, and his superb link-up play. He’s the embodiment of that false nine mentality that Arsenal seem to thrive on. He is. And for any listeners who might not be familiar with the term, a false nine is a striker who primarily drops deep into midfield to link play rather than staying high and challenging the centre backs.
19:05 And Jesus excels at that. Receiving the ball in tight spaces, knitting attacks together. It’s why when he returns from injury, the whole team instantly changes. They start passing the ball way more than they do to Gyokeres. He just fits Arteta ball perfectly. But his weaknesses are just as notorious. He’s frequently criticised as being a poor finisher. As the saying goes, he can’t finish a glass of water. It’s a common refrain and you have to add to that his worrying status as being made of glass. His frequent sometimes lengthy injury layoffs. It makes him a high-risk, high-reward option who doesn’t provide that consistent goal threat you need for a title challenge. Then you have Kai Havertz. And the fan consensus right now seems to suggest he’s the best fit for the system overall.
19:51 I’d agree. He strikes a superb balance, he offers good hold-up play, exceptional off-ball intelligence, and he’s fantastic in the air, which gives Arsenal a genuine aerial threat they often lack. He seems to be the tactical hybrid, doesn’t he? The perfect blend between the facilitator, Jesus, and the aerial threat you might expect from a more traditional number nine. He gives you the pressing intensity of Jesus, but he offers better presence in the box, and he runs the channels really intelligently. And his goals to appearance ratio is viewed by many as the best among the current options. Yeah, the general prediction is that he will be the main striker when everyone is fit. He does all the system required stuff, the pressing, the linking, the movement, but he adds genuine high percentage goal scoring on top. Which makes him indispensable to Arteta’s philosophy of control.
20:38 It does. And finally, the sources throw in a bit of a dark horse, Merino. Yes, Merino. He’s mentioned by several fans as a viable, false-9 option, or even, surprisingly, the best striker option because of his versatility and link-up capabilities. Particularly when the team needs extreme control in midfield. Exactly. And this array of choices, Jesus the technician, Havertz the hybrid presser, Gyokeres the vertical runner, and Merino the versatile link man. It highlights the sheer tactical spectrum available to Arteta. But it also accentuates the problem. It does. They haven’t settled on a single undisputed world class number nine who fits all the requirements. And this brings us right to the fundamental ideological clash that the Gyokeres transfer has exposed. The fan base is completely divided over who has to compromise. Is it the manager’s rigid system or is it the player’s unique goal-scoring profile? The majority viewpoint, certainly among those who defend Arteta, is that the manager is a prisoner of his own philosophy, but in a positive way.
21:45 Okay, what does that mean? They argue he’s unwilling to compromise on his principles precisely because those principles are what drive the team’s success. Defensive stability? Exactly. The fact that they concede the least goals in Europe is tied directly to that meticulous control and that caution in their build-up play. So if the system is sacred because it delivers success and defensive solidity, the logical conclusion is that Gyokeres has to be the one to adapt. He has to. Yeah. Which means he needs a radical overhaul. He needs to dramatically improve his technical game, his first touch, his passing, his build-up involvement. The whole lot. And that adaptation is often framed as him needing to become a Roberto Firmino type forward. Right. a deep-lying creative forward who links the play creates space for others, but also chips in with the odd goal.
22:33 That’s the idea, but the sources are quick to refute that comparison, aren’t they? They are. So why is Gyokeres not a viable Firmino successor? Because Firmino, during his peak at Liverpool, was just technically sublime. He had excellent hold-up play, control, first touch, and provided killer passes. And the critique of Gyokeres is… Is that he’s way behind his level as a false nine compared to Firmino. He simply does not possess the innate nuanced technical ability that you need to transform into that type of deep-lying creative forward. His profile was physical and vertical. Firmino’s was technical and creative. It’s like asking an apple to become an orange. Asking Gyokeres to become Firmino is asking him to entirely abandon his established identity. Which makes the counter argument so compelling.
23:18 Why on earth will you spend a reported 60 million pounds on a player whose goal-scoring record in the right system is undeniably brilliant, only to force him to abandon the one thing he does so well. It’s a very fair question. If he can’t adapt, then the cost versus the actual role he’s filling, which is a distraction player, it makes the entire transfer feel like a fundamental error in recruitment strategy. And that’s why the advocates for system change are so vocal. They demand that Arteta introduces more verticality. They want the team to pass quicker, take more risks and play the crucial through balls that actually exploit Gyokeres’s strengths rather than sticking to the current cautious game plan. They see this lack of service as coached caution.
24:04 Not a lack of ability from the players to see the pass. No, they believe the players could make the pass, but they’re being instructed not to. And this is where that anecdotal frustration, that compilation video comes back into play, painting such a vivid picture of the conflict. What exactly are fans seeing when they watch Gyokeres make these ignored runs? They’re seeing a striker executing the most valuable move in football, breaking the defensive line, only to be denied the ball. Can you give us an example? Okay so, Gyokeres might make a brilliant diagonal run that splits the two centre backs, forcing the entire opposition defence into a reactive scramble. But instead of Martin Odegaard releasing the early pass, he opts for the five yard sideways safety pass to Declan Rice. Exactly. And the immediate consequence is the opposition defence is allowed to just drop back, reset its low block, and that moment of genuine vulnerability is just… lost.
24:58 And this happens repeatedly. Over and over, which convinces this faction of the fanbase that the manager’s caution is actively costing them goals. The sources even speculate that if Arsenal played with the speed and the counter-attacking philosophy of their previous title challenging season, the 2022-23 season, Gyokeres would already have 25 plus goals and could potentially have delivered the league trophy that year. It suggests the philosophy shifted after he arrived. And that internal friction is massively amplified by the reported transfer intrigue. The sources widely suggest that Gyokeres was not Arteta’s first choice. Right, which would explain the tactical dissonance. It would. It’s reported that the director of football, Edu, perhaps influenced by external factors or specific agency relationships, was the one who pushed really hard for the Gyokeres signing. So if Edu pushed for Gyokeres, who did Arteta actually want?
25:51 Arteta was reportedly leaning towards profiles that better fit his technical and versatile mould, specifically Benjamin Sesko. Described as a gigantic dynamic striker he can mould. Exactly. Or Dusan Vlahovic. Both offer better technical hold-up play and are closer approximations to that hybrid false 9 role he seems to prefer. So if that managerial misalignment is accurate, it just contextualises the entire situation, doesn’t it? It really does. Arteta acquired a transitional vertical runner when he wanted a technical false 9. Now he’s forced to ask the player to fundamentally change his identity to fit the established system. Which is why the argument that spending 60 million on a player who’s then relegated to a distraction player or just a squad depth option is straight up dreadful business. Why that holds so much weight.
26:38 You invest that kind of sum expecting a nailed on starter, not a sophisticated decoy. And inevitably the discussion drags in Erling Haaland. Some fans defend the idea of building the team around Gyokeres by pointing to how Manchester City shifted to accommodate Haaland. But that comparison is strongly refuted within the source material. Very strongly. What’s the rebuttal to the Haaland comparison? Well, the counter argument is simple and, I think, quite powerful. Haaland was already a generational talent at 22. He was dominating the Champions League, setting scoring records in the Bundesliga. You adjust your entire system for a generational talent who has proven he’s world-class at the very highest level. Exactly. Conversely, Gyokeres at the same age was struggling at Brighton and Coventry.
27:26 He’s a talented player, making his first step up to that elite status not a proven global superstar. So the risk calculus is entirely different? Completely. The expectation remains that Gyokeres is the one who must adapt to the established title-contending system not the other way around. So we’ve established the conflict, the tactical mismatch. Now, where do the sources suggest this saga goes from here? The most sympathetic part of the fan base immediately points to the need for time. They cite the old “Thierry Henry needed time” defence. That argument suggests it’s just far too early to judge. He hasn’t even completed half a season of consistent fitness and starting games. Yeah. They argue that confidence and time are the missing elements, especially given that compromise preseason he had. And they have a powerful recent example right there in the squad with Kai Havertz.
28:13 They do. Havertz had an extremely slow start to his Arsenal career. He was facing massive fan criticism, yet after January, he found his stride completely integrated and became a must start. So what did Havertz change that Gyokeres now has to emulate? Havertz successfully adapted his off-ball intelligence to suit the system. He improved his press resistance and his movement in the final third to link the play, rather than just relying on raw pace. He found his niche as that hybrid false nine slash attacking eight. He did and for Gyokeres the proponents of patience believe that once he stops over thinking the technical stuff and just commits fully to the runs. And crucially once the confidence returns to allow the forward players to trust those runs. The goals will flow, that’s the belief. But patience is a luxury that Arsenal simply do not have right now. Exactly. The counter argument stresses the urgency of the title race. They’re battling Manchester City and you know a title can be lost in half a season. They can’t afford to wait a full year for a 60 million pound striker to adapt when every single point is critical. The pressure to deliver now favours the known system fitters, Jesus and Havertz. So if this adaptation fails, if this tactical knot cannot be untied, what are the proposed short-term and long-term resolutions that are coming out of the fan discourse?
29:33 In the short-term, the tactical consensus is quite pragmatic. Revert to playing Havertz and Jesus as the primary strikers when they’re fully fit. And Gyokeres gets relegated to a rotation or a plan B option. Mm. A plan B option. Yeah. He’s seen as most effective against teams that play a more open, high-pressing game because that leaves the necessary vertical space for him to exploit. But when facing the inevitable low block? The system prefers the technicality and the link-up play of the others. And the long-term view is much more drastic. It involves cutting their losses, which is a difficult conversation to have about a player signed so recently for such a huge fee. It is, but some sources are suggesting they sell him outright and reinvest the money into a profile that Arteta clearly prefers. And they’re floating ideas like swapping him for Sesko.
30:21 Swapping him for Sesko, who fans believe would thrive better at Arsenal due to his height and his technical mould Or looking for a completely different striker profile altogether. Names like Lautaro Martinez are mentioned. Lautaro Martinez, due to his trophy success and proven ability in a top league or even a strong technical target man in the mould of Olivier Giroud, someone who’s a better fit for breaking down low blocks with better hold-up play. You know, whether this transfer is ultimately deemed a failure or a long-term success, there is one undeniable positive outcome that the sources have highlighted. And what’s that? The depth and the tactical versatility that’s been created by having these four distinct striker profiles. That’s a very good point. Having Jesus, Havertz, Gyokeres and Merino means Arteta has tools for almost any tactical scenario.
31:10 He can switch between a technical facilitator like Jesus, a false nine aerial threat in Havertz, a transitional runner in Gyokeres, and a versatile link man in Merino. And that level of squad depth makes Arsenal much, much harder for opponents to predict and to strategise against. That versatility really is the silver lining in what many people are viewing as a tactical misstep or transfer misalignment. It is. If the gaffer can successfully implement a plan B that uses Gyokeres’s strengths when plan A, the slow possession hits a wall. Say in the last 20 minutes of a tight match. Exactly. Then the entire squad is infinitely stronger for it. So let’s review the key takeaways from this deep dive then. The paradox of Viktor Gyokeres is, well, it’s pretty extraordinary. He’s a vertical, powerful runner whose primary attacking movements are often ignored by his cautious teammates.
32:03 Yet his mere presence acts as this powerful decoy, forcing defensive shifts that arguably elevated the team’s overall consistency in the early part of the season. The conflict is stark, and it’s clear. The player, a specialist built for high-speed transitional football, is attempting to survive in a managerial philosophy that demands cautious, possession-heavy control against these entrenched low-block defences. So this whole debate isn’t really about Gyokeres’s fundamental quality? No, not at all. It’s about whether the system can afford to accommodate an outlier, even an outlier with a 60 million pound price tag and a European Golden Boot reputation. He is the classic case of the right player in the wrong system. Where the system is currently proving to be stubbornly inflexible. And that system inflexibility, that leads us to our final thought for you to mull over.
32:51 If Arsenal continues to rely primarily on strikers who are facilitators and link-up specialists, players like Jesus and Havertz, and consistently struggles to successfully integrate a prolific traditional volume goalscorer like Gyokeres. Yeah. Does that suggest that Mikel Arteta’s tactical system has permanently sacrificed the idea of signing and utilising a 25-plus goal a season striker, all for the sake of achieving absolute system control and unparalleled defensive stability? So is control ultimately the currency of success at the Emirates, even if it comes at the expense of guaranteed firepower? That’s the question.
This transcript was made with Whisper speech recognition, with names checked against the show notes. The hosts are AI voices, and their words are kept as spoken; anything they got wrong is corrected in a dated note on this page.
Sources
- Sky Sports: Viktor Gyokeres joins Arsenal: Sporting striker completes transfer to Premier League club, signing five-year deal (27 July 2025)
- Al Jazeera: Kylian Mbappe wins European Golden Shoe award for first time (26 May 2025)
- Sky Sports: Viktor Gyokeres needs to do more to keep hold of Arsenal place as Gabriel Jesus returns, by Nick Wright (20 December 2025)
- Premier League: Gyokeres ends goal drought as Arsenal regain top spot at Everton (20 December 2025)
- Opta Analyst: Is Mikel Arteta Right: Are Arsenal Better With Viktor Gyokeres?, by Ali Tweedale (8 January 2026)
- Opta Analyst: Viktor Gyokeres Has More Goals in His Debut Season Than Some Arsenal Greats, So Does He Deserve More Respect?, by Oliver Hopkins (5 May 2026)
- Sky Sports: Edu: Arsenal sporting director to leave club with Gunners surprised by his decision (4 November 2024)
- Premier League: Arsenal end 22-year wait for Premier League title (19 May 2026)
- Fan reaction: Arsenal and Sporting supporters on social media and fan forums
Fact-checked by Ram Gohil on 17 November 2026.
