Home » Sports Podcast » Man Utd 2-0 Man City: How Carrick Won His First Game Back

Manchester United beat Manchester City 2-0 at Old Trafford on 17 January 2026 in Michael Carrick’s first game back in charge, with goals from Bryan Mbeumo and Patrick Dorgu. We break down the switch to 4-2-3-1, Lisandro Martinez v Erling Haaland, City’s toothless display and the fan reaction.

23 minThe AI-thletic Sports Podcast

How this was made: the hosts are AI voices. Ram Gohil chooses the topic, directs the episode and fact-checks this page. The transcript is made by speech recognition and checked for names. How we create our content

Listen to this episode

▶
Play Spotify episode

Listen on Spotify Listen on Apple Podcasts

Key quotes

What did Michael Carrick say after Manchester United 2-0 Manchester City?

Carrick called it “a special day”, adding: “We’re not getting carried away” (Premier League).

How did Pep Guardiola react to the derby defeat?

“They had the energy we didn’t have,” Guardiola said, adding: “The better team won” (Premier League).

What did Lisandro Martinez say after the win?

“When we are together, it is impossible to lose at home,” Martinez said (Premier League).

Chapters

  1. 0:00 A scoreline that flattered City
  2. 0:46 From funeral to celebration in a week
  3. 1:36 The sources and the fan reaction
  4. 2:21 New manager bounce or proof of a broken system?
  5. 3:10 “Unbelievably desperate to do well”
  6. 3:56 Why fans felt gaslit
  7. 4:44 Back to a 4-2-3-1
  8. 5:39 Bruno Fernandes back at No 10
  9. 6:25 What United DNA really means
  10. 7:12 Controlled chaos on the counter
  11. 7:59 The expected goals gap
  12. 8:47 Disallowed goals and the woodwork
  13. 9:49 Donnarumma keeps the score down
  14. 10:36 The pundits and Lisandro Martinez
  15. 11:22 Martinez v Haaland
  16. 12:22 Maguire the warrior
  17. 13:08 A backbone at the back
  18. 14:03 Dalot’s lucky escape
  19. 14:49 Casemiro rolls back the years
  20. 15:45 Kobbie Mainoo’s return
  21. 16:32 Mainoo the connector
  22. 17:22 Meltdown on the City forums
  23. 18:08 Injuries and a “spineless” display
  24. 19:08 Is Carrick the one?
  25. 19:53 The Solskjaer warning
  26. 20:41 The low-block test
  27. 21:26 Legends in the dugout v legends in the studio
  28. 22:12 The case for caution
  29. 23:07 Why the next games matter

What happened in Manchester United 2-0 Manchester City?

United won the derby at Old Trafford on 17 January 2026 in Michael Carrick’s first match of his second spell in charge (Premier League). Bryan Mbeumo finished a counter-attack from a City free-kick, after exchanging passes with Bruno Fernandes, on 65 minutes, and Patrick Dorgu headed in substitute Matheus Cunha’s cross on 76 (Manchester United). United also had three goals ruled out for offside and hit the woodwork twice, through Harry Maguire’s early header and Amad’s shot against the post (Premier League, Manchester United). It was United’s first win over City at Old Trafford since January 2023 (Premier League).

How did Michael Carrick set Manchester United up against City?

With a simpler 4-2-3-1. Carrick switched from Ruben Amorim’s 3-4-2-1 to a back four, and Kobbie Mainoo, who had not started a Premier League game since May, gave United “some fluency and control in midfield” (Premier League). In the episode we explain why moving Fernandes back to the No 10 role and pairing Casemiro with Mainoo in a compact shape suited the players, and why so many fans felt the old system had hidden their strengths.

How did Lisandro Martinez handle Erling Haaland?

Comfortably. Haaland had only 14 touches before being taken off with 10 minutes to go (Opta Analyst), and Martinez blocked his one dangerous shot on the turn (Manchester United). We discuss the pre-match debate about Martinez’s height and the pundit comments the hosts say fired him up, which we could not verify. Martinez said afterwards: “When we are together, it is impossible to lose at home” (Premier League).

Why were Manchester City so poor at Old Trafford?

In our view, because a weakened, sluggish side could not match United’s energy. City’s expected goals figure of 0.45 was their second-lowest in nine years under Pep Guardiola (Premier League), and the defeat left them winless in four league games in 2026 and six points behind leaders Arsenal, having played a game more (Premier League). Guardiola admitted: “They had the energy we didn’t have” (Premier League).

Was the derby win just a new manager bounce for Carrick?

Partly, but it lasted longer than most. United won 3-2 at Arsenal in Carrick’s next game (Premier League), and he was given the job until 2028 on 22 May after guiding United to third (Reuters). The sceptics’ comparison with Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, another interim who got the job permanently, proved uncomfortably apt when Carrick left on 12 November after what the club called “a disappointing start to the season” (Manchester United).

Discussion points

  1. Was the derby win proof that Ruben Amorim’s system was holding United back, or just a new manager bounce?
  2. Should pundits who are club legends hold back from criticising the current players?
  3. Which United player gained most from Carrick’s changes: Fernandes, Mainoo, Casemiro or Martinez?

Full transcript

Read the full transcript

0:00 Hello and welcome to the Deep Dive. Today we are transporting you straight to the heart of Manchester. It is January 18th, 2026. Yes. The rain has stopped, the floodlights are powering down, but the noise, I mean, the noise is still ringing in ears all across the city. Oh, for sure. If you’ve glanced at a screen, a newspaper, or even spoken to another human being in the last 24 hours, you know the headline. Manchester United 2, Manchester City 0. And honestly, that score line is the biggest lie of the weekend. It flatters City. It really, really does. It’s just wild to say that about a Pep Guardiola team, isn’t it? It is. Usually, if you beat City, you’ve survived a siege. You’ve parked the bus. The keepers made 15 saves. And you’ve nicked one on the break. Absolutely, a smash and grab.

0:46 But we’re here to unpack what feels like a collective hallucination for United fans. Just seven days ago, the vibe was, well, it was a funeral. It was grim. Ruben Amorim had been sacked, the season was written off, and the forums were just spiraling into toxicity. The mood music was essentially relegation form talk. Exactly. And then enter Michael Carrick. Three days of training, 72 hours. That’s it. And suddenly, United produced a performance that many sources, and look, not just United fan channels, but neutral journalists too, are calling the best performance since the glory days. It is a fascinating case study because we aren’t just looking at a football match today. No, we’re looking at psychology, we’re looking at the art of tactical simplification, and we’re looking at some absolutely brutal data that suggests this was a historic beating.

1:36 We have got a massive stack of sources to get through today. We’ve combed through the post-match press conferences from Carrick and Pep Guardiola. We’ve got the deep dive tactical data on XG and player positioning and my personal favourite, we’ve got the raw unfiltered fan reactions from the subreddit. Which are absolute gold dust today. Oh, they are. The contrast between r/reddevils and r/MCFC is just. It’s stark. It’s arguably the biggest mood swing I’ve seen in Premier League online discourse in about five years. It really is. So here’s the mission for the deep dive. We need to answer the big question floating around the internet. Okay. Was this just a new manager bounce? You know, that sugar rush of adrenaline when the boss gets sacked? Right.

2:21 Or did Michael Carrick just expose in 90 minutes that the previous regime was getting it systematically wrong? That is the million dollar question, isn’t it? Yeah. Because the narrative shift has been violent. We went from these players aren’t good enough for the Premier League. To these players were being handcuffed by the system. In the space of one afternoon, it’s incredible. Let’s start with the atmosphere and the psychology. Because before a ball was even kicked, something felt different. You found some sources discussing the Carrick effect on the player’s mental state. Yeah, this is crucial context. You often hear about the new manager bounce, right? It’s almost a cliche in football. It is. The strict teacher leaves, the substitute teacher comes in, the pressure lifts, and everyone runs a bit harder to impress. But looking at the reports from the training ground this week, this was deeper than just effort.

3:10 Deeper how? Michael Carrick mentioned in his post-match comments that the players were unbelievably desperate to do well. Desperate is a strong word, isn’t it? It’s a very strong word. Usually managers say motivated or ready. Desperate implies a kind of frantic energy almost like they were cornered animals. Exactly and Carrick actually said he was worried about that. Yeah. He said he feared they might be too desperate. Oh okay. He thought they might lose their heads, fly into tackles, get a red card in the first 10 minutes, or just run themselves into the ground by halftime. So, he had to manage that energy. He had to actively work to calm them down, to channel that desperation into discipline. That is a great detail. It suggests they weren’t just playing for points. They were playing to prove a point.

3:56 They took the criticism personally. Spot on. And that emotional release leads directly into the tactical shift. We have to talk about the gaslighting narrative that has popped up in the fan forums. Oh, I saw this everywhere. It was a recurring theme in the source material. It’s a heavy term, gaslighting. Explain that for the listener who might not be scrolling the forums all day. Why do fans feel gaslighted by the previous manager? Well, think about the Ruben Amorim era. The system was incredibly complex. We’re talking inverted wingbacks, box midfields, false nines dropping into false positions to create overloads that… That never seemed to materialise. Right. And when it didn’t work, which was often, the implied message from the management was always the system is genius, but the players don’t have the football IQ to execute it.

4:44 Right. So the fans start believing, okay, our squad must be terrible. These players just can’t learn. We need to sell everyone. Precisely. You start to doubt your own eyes. Then Carrick walks in. He strips it all back. He plays a 4-2-3-1. Simple. He puts players in their natural habitats, and suddenly they look world-class. That’s why fans feel gaslighted. They realise the squad wasn’t the problem. The instructions were. And the absolute poster boy for this shift is Bruno Fernandes. We have to talk about Bruno. This was the biggest tactical gripe fans had for months. Under Amorim, seeing him play as a number six or deep in that pivot, it was painful to watch. Fans were calling it criminal in the threads. And you know what? Statistically, they’re right. Oh, so? You take your best chaos agent, the guy who sees passes nobody else sees, the guy who thrives on high-risk, high-reward football, and you ask him to defend transitions 40 yards from the opponent’s goal.

5:39 It’s like buying a Ferrari and using it to plow a field. It’s just a misuse of resources. Exactly. So Carrick puts him back at number 10, the classic creator role, right behind the striker. And what happened? Magic happened. The data here is staggering. Bruno created over six clear cut chances in this game. Six. Against Manchester City. It’s a Pep Guardiola City side. That is a Premier League record for a single player against Pep and he got an assist Wow, but more importantly he looked happy He was pressing from the front triggering the press taking risks under Amorim. Every time he lost the ball trying a risky pass He looked terrified of the bench because he was breaking the structure yesterday. He played with freedom total freedom It sounds so simple when you break it down. Put your best creator in the creating spot.

6:25 Who knew? Who thought? But let’s zoom out to the team identity. This phrase, United DNA gets thrown around a lot. Oh, all the time. Usually by pundits trying to fill airtime or ex-players reminiscing about the 90s. But yesterday, looking at the heat maps and the passing networks, it actually meant something tangible. It did. United DNA, in a tactical sense, not a marketing sense, refers to pace, directness, and risk-taking in transition. It’s about verticality. Verticality. Let’s unpack that term for a second. We mean getting the ball forward fast rather than side to side. Exactly. Look at the possession stats. City actually had about 62% of the ball. Right. If you just looked at possession on teletext, you might think City dominated, but they did absolutely nothing with it. It was sterile possession.

7:12 A horseshoe of sadness. Passing in a horseshoe shape around the defence. Exactly. United, meanwhile, were electric. Every time they won the ball, the first thought was forward. I saw a comparison on social media to the Ole Gunnar Solskjaer era. People saying it felt like the best of the Ole counter-attacks, specifically that 2019 win at the Etihad. It is a fair comparison, but sources noted a key difference. Okay. Under Ole, games often turned into basketball matches. End to end, chaos, you score, we score. It was fun, but it was loose. But very loose. Here, Carrick’s United had a rigid defensive shape. They were compact, they suffered without the ball comfortably, and then bang, spring the trap. It was controlled chaos. And that trap was lethal. We mentioned earlier that the scoreline flattered City.

7:59 Let’s dig into the battering section of our notes. Yes. Because 2-0 sounds like a comfortable professional win, but the underlying numbers suggest a massacre. If we look at the XG expected goals, it tells a horror story for Manchester City. Right. Now, for anyone not obsessed with analytics, let’s briefly explain XG. It basically measures the quality of a chance based on thousands of historical shots. A penalty is 0.79 XG, meaning 79% of the time it’s a goal. And a shot from the halfway line is maybe.01? Exactly. So higher is better. It means you’re creating chances that should be goals. Much better. So what were the numbers in this game? In this game, depending on the model you use, Understat, Opta, etc, United generated between 3.81 and 4.45 xg. Wow, nearly four and a half expected goals?

8:47 That is massive. And City… The paltry 0.47. 0.47. For a team with Haaland, Foden, Silva, that is unheard of. It is historic. According to the xG Philosophy, which we have in our source pile, this was Man City’s biggest ever XG defeat under Pep Guardiola. Ever. Ever in any competition. They barely registered a meaningful shot on target. That is scathing. I mean, we’re used to City maybe losing one nil on a counter attack, but usually they’ve battered the door down for 90 minutes to create nothing. That is a systemic failure. And let’s not forget the almost moments. Yeah. United had the ball in the net five times. Five times. I remember the offside calls. Three disallowed goals. Sure, offside is offside. The linesman flag went up. The margins were razor thin. So thin. It shows that the defensive line of City was being shredded repeatedly. They just couldn’t cope with the runners in behind. Then you have the woodwork. Harry Maguire hit the bar with a header. And Amad hit the post with that curler. Exactly. So we are legitimately talking about a potential 5-0 or 6-0 demolition here.

9:49 Without Gianluigi Donnarumma in goal for City, it is 6-0. He made three world-class saves. He was their man of the match, easily. He and Khusanov were the only City players who escaped criticism in the post-match ratings. Everyone else. Zeros and ones. It was a battering in everything but the final score. It’s incredible to think about just days after Amorim leaves, the team produces that kind of attacking output. But you mentioned Maguire hitting the bar and that segues us perfectly to the other end of the pitch. Because as much as the attack was sparkling, the defence was nasty in a good way. Oh, the pundit wars. This was the narrative arc of the weekend. Set the scene for us because this started way before kickoff. This wasn’t just post-match analysis. This was pre-match provocation. Right. So midweek you have the class of 92 podcast.

10:36 Paul Scholes, Nicky Butt, Gary Neville, legends of the club obviously. Of course. And they’re discussing the upcoming derby. And the topic of Lisandro Martinez comes up. And let me guess. They talked about his height. Again. It is the lazy narrative that just will not die. It doesn’t matter how many clean sheets he keeps. If they lose, it’s because he’s short. Right. But Nicky Butt took it a step further this time. He made a comment that went viral instantly. Oh, I saw this one. He said, Erling Haaland would, and I quote, pick Martinez up and run with him like a dad running with a kid. Like a dad running with a kid. I mean, ouch. Ouch. That is vivid imagery. It is. It’s funny in a pub banter sort of way, but it’s also wildly disrespectful to a World Cup winner. It was incredibly dismissive.

11:22 It treats Martinez like a mascot rather than an elite centre back. And judging by the performance, I think Martinez heard it. You think so? Because what we saw on the pitch was a master class in aggression, timing, and leverage. Martinez the butcher absolutely pocketed Haaland. He didn’t just win the ball. He dominated the physical battle. There’s a great thread on the forum analysing how Martinez uses his low centre of gravity. Yeah, he gets underneath the taller players and unbalances them. And Haaland hates that. Hates it. He’s a giant. He wants a defender to lean on him so he can use his strength to roll them. Martinez doesn’t give him that leverage. He nips in front or he bumps him just as the ball arrives, knocking him off stride. And the reaction on social media was euphoric. And Martinez has actually addressed the pundits in his post-match interview. I saw this. He didn’t hold back, did he? No. He said people can say whatever with that classic Martinez smirk. And then he invited Scholes to come to his house.

12:22 I love that. Come to my house. I assume to see the World Cup medal or maybe just to have a chat about the art of defending. Who knows? But it wasn’t just Martinez, was it? The man next to him had quite a day too. Harry Maguire. The redemption arc that never ends. Maguire was described as a warrior in almost every match report we pulled. He finished the game with bloody knees, didn’t he? Bloody knees, head strapped up, it was proper old school centre half stuff, Terry Butcher vibes. Proper. But there was a moment in the second half that fans were obsessing over. Maguire physically handling Bernardo Silva. The pick up and throw. That’s how they described it. Silva tried to shield the ball near the corner flag, and Maguire just moved him, like he was weaving a piece of furniture to vacuum underneath it.

13:08 Just a statement. It was a statement. You are not passing. You are not keeping this ball. It is funny because for so long the defence has looked fragile, soft centred. So soft. But you put Maguire and Martinez back together, a partnership that actually worked well under Ten Hag in the early days and suddenly there’s a backbone. That is the key word, backbone. Under Amorim, the constant changing of systems, back three, back four, hybrid roles, made the defence look hesitant. And hesitation kills defenders. It does. If you have to think for a split second, am I the inverted wingback or the third centre half? Well, the striker is already gone. Yesterday, their jobs were simple. You mark him, you hit the ball, and they look like a brick wall. Even Diogo Dalot, who can be a bit chaotic, had his moment. A mixed bag for Dalot. He made a goal line clearance that was absolutely vital when the score was one nil. If that goes in, it’s a different game. 100%.

14:03 But we have to be objective. He also put in a tackle that Pep Guardiola was furious about. Pep mentioned that in the presser, right? He did. Pep admitted United were the better team. But he felt Dalot should have been sent off for a high boot. Really? He said it would have changed the game dynamics. And looking at the replay, Dalot was lucky. It was an orange card. Borderline red. Sometimes you need that luck in a derby though. You need the rub of the green. Absolutely. But let’s move into the engine room. Because if the defence was the backbone, the midfield was the lungs. And there’s one man we have to salute. Uncle Case. Casemiro. Written off by so many. His legs have gone he’s too old. He’s turning like a cruise ship. I’ll admit I’ve thought it myself watching him recently. We all have.

14:49 And yet yesterday. Colossal. The sources say he played like he was 25 again. He was everywhere, breaking up plays, starting attacks, winning headers in his own box, and then appearing in the opponent’s box. How do you explain that? You can’t just physically get younger in a week. Did Carrick find a time machine at Carrington? It comes back to the system. It always does. Casemiro is an elite reader of the game, but he lacks recovery pace. We know this. We do? If you play a wide-open, chaotic system, like Amorim sometimes did, or Ten Hag at the end, you are asking Casemiro to cover 50 yards of open grass. He can’t do that anymore, he gets exposed. Right, it’s like asking a tank to drag race a Formula One car, it’s not built for it. Exactly. But Carrick played a compact structure. The distances between the defenders and the midfielders were short, maybe 10 or 15 yards. So he didn’t have to sprint? He just had to step left, step right, intercept. He was protected by the structure. And the description of him at the end of the game?

15:45 Oh, beautiful scenes. Standing at the Stretford End, arms wide, soaking up the noise. The fans love him for that. They do. Fans are posting that they want him to get a one-year extension, even on his crazy wages, just because that experience is so vital for the young lads, It went from sell him to Saudi Arabia to give him the armband in 90 minutes. The turnaround is amazing. And speaking of young lads, we have to talk about the partner in crime. The lost time of Kobbie Mainoo. This is a sore spot for the fan base regarding the previous manager. It really validates the fan frustration under Amorim, Mainoo was basically a ghost. Sidelined. Worse than sideline. There were leaks suggesting he wasn’t tactically disciplined enough. Which is just mad. There were even rumours of a loan move in January.

16:32 Can you imagine? Loaning out your generational [unclear], the kid who scored in the FA Cup final. The fans would have burned the stadium down. Well, Carrick put him straight back in. Mainoo looked fresh. He looked hungry. But tactically, this is interesting. He formed a pivot with Casemiro, but he wasn’t just sitting. No. He acts as a connector. Define that for us. What is a connector in this system? So you have Casemiro destroying attacks. You have Bruno creating them up top. Mainoo’s the bridge. He takes the ball from the defenders under pressure, spins away, which is a superpower, and drives the ball to Bruno. He knits the whole team together. He links the back to the front. He’s so important. And the sources suggest the Amorim was holding him back narrative is now the dominant truth? Completely. It raises serious questions about talent identification under the previous regime.

17:22 How can you watch Kobbie Mainoo in training and think, I can’t use this player? It baffles the mind. It makes people question if Amorim was overthinking it, you know, trying to be too clever. Precisely. Now we have been very united focused naturally because they won. Of course. But we have to look at the blue corner because as good as united were, the reaction from the city camp is, well, apocalyptic is the word. It is a full-blown meltdown I spent some time on r/MCFC and the mood is dark. We mentioned Pep was gracious admitting the better team won but the fans Not so much. No They are furious and what’s interesting is the target of their anger. It’s not just the players There are genuine threads claiming Pep has lost the plot.

18:08 Lost the plot. The man who won the treble, the man who has dominated English football for a decade. Football fans are fickle, aren’t they? Incredibly fickle. But there are legitimate grievances here. City are in the midst of an injury crisis. Ruben Dias, Josko Gvardiol, John Stones, Rodri. They were all mentioned as missing or not fully fit. So the squad is thin. It is. But the fans aren’t accepting that as an excuse for the manner of the defeat. They used the word spineless, didn’t they? Spineless, hiding, toothless. The stat that they had zero shots on target for the vast majority of the game is being used as a stick to beat the team With right it wasn’t just losing. It was the lack of fight in a derby That’s the thing about derbies you can lose, but you have to kick someone you have to show you care You can’t just stroll around Exactly and specific players were getting it in the neck Rico Lewis and Matheus Nunes came in for heavy criticism fans felt they were simply not up to the physical standard required for a game of this magnitude.

19:08 They were bullied by Mainoo and Casemiro. Completely. It is rare to see a City team outworked. Outplayed maybe occasionally, but outworked. That is alarming for them. It is. And for City fans, looking at their rivals who have been [unclear] for months, let’s be honest, suddenly looking more cohesive and hungry than them. That hurts more than the three points. It stings. So bringing it all together, we have the Carrick Masterclass, the City Meltdown, the Redemption Arcs. Now we have to ask the big question about the future. Is Michael Carrick the one? This is the dilemma the fan base is grappling with right now. You can see the split in the threads. Half of them are euphoric, posting memes saying, give them the contract immediately. [unclear] Right. They see the connection, the style, the results.

19:53 And the other half. The other half are suffering from PTSD. They remember the Ole Gunnar Solskjaer era too vividly. Remember. Ole came in as interim, won a load of games including that famous night in Paris, got the permanent job and then… Well, the wheels fell off. [unclear] Sugar rush wears off and you realise you haven’t eaten a proper meal in weeks. Exactly. The argument from the sceptics is this. Beating City at Old Trafford when the crowd is up for it and you can play on the counter-attack with space to run into. That is one thing. That suits United’s players. It does. They love space. Yeah. But can you break down a low block away at Fulham or Brentford? Just to clarify, low block for everyone. That’s when the other team basically puts all 10 players in their own penalty box and dares you to score, right?

20:41 Correct. Yeah. It’s tough. You need intricate passing patterns. You need patience. We don’t know if Carrick can coach that yet. We haven’t seen it. That is the real test. It’s easy to look good when there is space. It’s much harder when there are 10 men behind the ball on a rainy Tuesday and you have to craft a goal out of nothing. Precisely. But Carrick has immediately put himself in pole position. He carries that united man status. And seeing the ownership reaction, Sir Jim Ratcliffe was spotted celebrating in the stands, suggests the hierarchy is paying close attention. It must be a relief for the owners too. They made the big call to sack Amorim. If they had lost this game 3-0, the pressure on Jason Wilcox and the technical team would have been immense. Questions about why did you sack him would have been everywhere. Huge validation.

21:26 They decided to trust the old boys, Carrick, Darren Fletcher, to steady the ship and it has paid off instantly. Speaking of old boys, we touched on this earlier with the Pundit Wars, but there is a fascinating tension there. You have the fans loving the legend in the dugout, Carrick, but loathing the legends in the studio, Neville, Scholes. It is a really nuanced dynamic. It feels like a civil war among the legends. There is a feeling that the class of 92 pundits have become clickbait merchants, that they’re more interested in generating headlines for Sky Sports than actually supporting the club. The Martinez comments were the tipping point. I think so too. Fans feel like if you are a legend, support the players. Don’t mock them. Don’t give the opposition dressing room ammunition.

22:12 It shows that legend’s status isn’t a free pass anymore. You have to earn the respect of the modern fan. You can’t just rest on your medals. Spot on. The fan base is protective of this current squad now, especially after a performance like that. So what a weekend for Manchester United. A 2-0 win that could have been 5-0. A tactical masterclass. A silenced Erling Haaland. It doesn’t get much better. It really doesn’t. But, and I have to be the voice of reason here. Much as I hate it. I think you’re gonna do this. Go on, ruin the party. Be the wet blanket. I have to. We have seen this movie before. The New Manager Bounce is a real statistical phenomenon. The energy levels naturally drop after a few weeks. Sure. The tactical simplicity works now because it’s fresh and the players are liberated. But once teams figure out Carrick’s 4-2-3-1, does he have a plan B? That is the provocative thought to leave you with. Was the problem really Amorim’s complex system?

23:07 Or are we just seeing the temporary relief of a squad that got its way? The Fulham game next week might actually tell us more about Michael Carrick’s managerial future than this Derby win ever could. If he wins there, ugly, 1-0. Then we can start talking. Then we can start talking about contracts. Indeed. But for now, let the fans enjoy the bragging rights. Manchester is red. Thanks for listening to The Deep Dive. Thanks everyone. We will be watching that Fulham game very closely. Until next time, take care.

This transcript was made with Whisper speech recognition, with names checked against the show notes. The hosts are AI voices, and their words are kept as spoken; anything they got wrong is corrected in a dated note on this page.

Sources

Fact-checked by on 17 November 2026.