Two years after his sacking, Erik ten Hag gave The Athletic his account of INEOS’s broken promises, the McTominay sale, his transfer record and his clash with Cristiano Ronaldo. This episode tests his version against the reaction of Manchester United fans.
Listen to this episode
Key quotes
What did Erik ten Hag say about INEOS’s promises?
“They promised me loyalty, they promised me backing, they promised communication,” Ten Hag told The Athletic, and he said one broken promise was keeping Scott McTominay (Sky Sports).
What did Erik ten Hag say about Cristiano Ronaldo?
“He let the team down, and he let me down, because we planned with him,” Ten Hag said; Ronaldo’s representative did not respond (Sky Sports).
What did Erik ten Hag say about Michael Carrick?
“It is not the solution to dismiss him. 100 per cent not,” Ten Hag said in October 2026; United confirmed Carrick’s departure on 12 November (Sky Sports, Manchester United).
Chapters
- 0:00 Ten Hag breaks his silence
- 0:50 Why this interview matters
- 1:35 The sources and the plan
- 2:25 Replacements courted before the FA Cup final
- 3:23 No bitterness towards the club
- 4:16 The noise of the INEOS takeover
- 5:01 A leadership vacuum
- 6:29 The Ibiza deal
- 7:27 The McTominay promise
- 8:58 Fans on broken promises
- 10:32 “The data was showing we are good”
- 11:28 Results versus process
- 12:17 Signs the end was coming
- 13:04 “Just tell me”
- 14:11 Ratcliffe and the head coach structure
- 14:56 Ten Hag defends Carrick
- 15:43 Fans on Carrick and the board
- 17:30 FC Twente and the tactical brief
- 18:17 The profiles he asked for
- 19:29 Control without accountability?
- 20:16 Antony and the cost of amortisation
- 21:31 The agency question
- 22:21 De Jong, Rice and Kane
- 23:07 Why he wanted mature leaders
- 23:53 Fans on the transfer record
- 24:40 Player power and Rashford
- 25:30 Ronaldo: “He let the team down”
- 27:05 “Save your legs”
- 27:50 The Madrid connection
- 28:38 How fans see Ronaldo’s legacy
- 29:27 Was moving Ronaldo on the right call?
- 31:14 Managing egos at Old Trafford
- 32:00 What it all means
- 32:45 Is United unmanageable?
What did Erik ten Hag say about Manchester United in his 2026 interview?
Erik ten Hag told The Athletic’s Laurie Whitwell, over two evenings in Enschede in October 2026, that INEOS broke the promises it made when it extended his contract in 2024, and that Cristiano Ronaldo let the team down (Sky Sports). Two years after his sacking, and now technical director at his boyhood club FC Twente, he still spoke warmly of the club itself: “I enjoyed every minute in Manchester United; I have such wonderful memories” (Sky Sports). He added: “I really want United to win. I want them to be successful again” (Heart). In this episode we work through the interview alongside the reaction from United fans on Reddit, and we test his version of events rather than taking it at face value.
What promises did INEOS break, according to Ten Hag?
Loyalty, backing and communication. After United beat Manchester City 2-1 in the 2024 FA Cup final, Ten Hag agreed a one-year extension following talks in Ibiza, and he says “They promised me loyalty, they promised me backing, they promised communication” (Sky Sports). One promise he says was broken was keeping Scott McTominay, who was sold to Napoli (Sky Sports). He also described the takeover itself: “The takeover process brought a lot of noise, uncertainty with the people, and disruptions” (Sky Sports). He was sacked on 28 October 2024, the day after a 2-1 defeat by West Ham, with United 14th on 11 points from nine games (Sky Sports). We think his complaint about communication is fair, but his argument that the data showed the team was improving was always going to struggle at a club judged on results.
Was Ten Hag responsible for Manchester United’s transfer mistakes?
Partly, in our view. In the hosts’ reading of his words, Ten Hag made control over transfers a condition of the job, yet says he was never involved in negotiating fees. United paid £86m for Antony from Ajax in 2022 (Sky Sports), a deal many fans still hold against him, and Reddit users also pointed to signings linked to his agency. Ten Hag says the player he really wanted was Harry Kane (Sky Sports), and the hosts also discuss his pursuit of Declan Rice and Frenkie de Jong as the kind of mature, accountable leaders he felt the squad lacked. The hosts argue that a manager cannot ask for the power to pick players and then disown the bill, and we agree that this is the weakest part of his case.
What did Ten Hag say about Cristiano Ronaldo?
That Ronaldo “let the team down, and he let me down, because we planned with him” (Sky Sports). Ten Hag says Ronaldo did not reach the required fitness levels and, after the 4-0 defeat at Brentford in August 2022, did only two of the three laps of a post-match run; Ronaldo’s representative did not respond to The Athletic (Sky Sports). In the hosts’ telling, Ten Hag also blamed a “Madrid connection” of senior players for a culture of player power. Fans were split: many said moving Ronaldo on was the best thing Ten Hag did, while others doubted the most serious claims, such as Ronaldo telling team-mates to save their legs in training. We would treat those claims as one side of a bitter divorce.
What happened to Michael Carrick after Ten Hag’s interview?
He left within a month. Ten Hag had said of Carrick: “It is not the solution to dismiss him. 100 per cent not” (Sky Sports), but Manchester United confirmed on 12 November 2026 that Carrick had left after “a disappointing start to the season” (Manchester United). That answers, in part, the question the episode ends on: whether anyone can manage the modern United when the club keeps changing course. In our view, Ten Hag’s warning about impatience looks more convincing in hindsight than his defence of his own record.
Discussion points
- Was Erik ten Hag let down by INEOS, or did his results make his sacking inevitable?
- Should a manager who demands control of transfers take responsibility for the fees?
- Can anyone succeed as Manchester United manager without the board’s full backing?
Full transcript
Read the full transcript
0:00 picture the scene, right? It is October 2026. Right. The autumn chill has, you know, settled over the east of the Netherlands. And it has been two full, just completely chaotic years since Erik ten Hag was unceremoniously sacked by Manchester United back in the autumn of 2024. Yeah, two whole years. Exactly. And he has retreated completely from that glaring toxic spotlight of the British tabloids. He’s safely back in his hometown of Enschede, operating as the technical director of his boyhood club FC Twente. Which is probably a relief for him, honestly. Oh, totally. And after two years of absolute disciplined silence, the Dutchman has sat down for two incredibly long, intense evenings with The Athletic to just simply unburden himself.
0:50 It really is a remarkable piece of sports journalism because what you are getting isn’t some PR managed sanitised press release carefully crafted by crisis managers. Right. No spin. Exactly. No spin. This is a manager who stood in the absolute epicenter of the world’s biggest, most unforgiving sporting storm, trying to process exactly what happened to him, to his reputation and, well, his footballing philosophy. Which brings us to our mission today. We are designing this deep dive specifically for you, the listener. Yeah, just bypass all the noise. Exactly. We are going to bypass the clickbait, the screaming pundits, and the manufactured outrage. We are going to extract the raw, unfiltered truth from a massive stack of sources today.
1:35 And we have a lot to get through. We really do. We have Ten Hag’s explosive sprawling interview. We have the meta audio commentary surrounding the piece. And crucially, we are going fundamentally into the fiery polarised and frankly incredibly insightful reactions from the British fan community on Reddit. Because the fans are the ones who ultimately have to live with the consequences you know. Right. Long after the executives and coaches pack up their multi-million pound severance cheques and leave the fans remain. Their reactions their cynicism and their exhausted loyalty are just as much a part of the historical record as the interview itself. Okay, let’s unpack this. We have a clear blueprint for you today. First, we’ll expose the boardroom betrayals. Then we’ll dissect the chaotic transfer strategy. And finally, we’ll dive into the toxic dressing room culture and that ultimate showdown with Cristiano Ronaldo.
2:25 Sounds like a plan. So to really understand the sheer chaos of Ten Hag’s tenure, we have to begin at the end. You cannot fully grasp what went wrong on the pitch until you understand the bizarre, almost Shakespearean circumstances of his departure. It was quite frankly surreal from a corporate governance standpoint. Wild. You have to contextualise the environment leading up to that 2024 FA Cup final against Manchester City. The media landscape is completely saturated with verified reports that INEOS… The new minority owners, right. Right. The owners who had just taken total control of football operations. They are openly, brazenly courting his replacements right before the final. Yeah, Thomas Tuchel, Roberto De Zerbi, Kieran McKenna. I want you to imagine trying to prepare a squad of highly paid, highly ego-driven athletes for a cup final against Pep Guardiola when every single player knows your bosses are interviewing your replacement.
3:23 It’s an impossible working environment. It is. But despite all of that very public betrayal, the lingering affection Ten Hag has for the institution of Manchester United is kind of staggering. Listen to these exact words. He says, quote, I enjoyed every minute of Manchester United. I have such wonderful memories, unquote. Which if we look at it objectively, sounds almost like a form of sporting Stockholm syndrome. Honestly, yeah. Given the relentless pressure cooker he endured. But it speaks to the intoxicating gravity of Old Trafford. It really does. He goes even further to separate the fans from the executives. He says, quote, it feels like I’m connected. I’m a fan. It’s an amazing fan base. They were always respectful to me. What’s fascinating here is the complete lack of bitterness towards the badge itself. He fundamentally separates the club from the executives.
4:16 Right. He even adds, quote, I really want United to win. I want them to be successful again. I want the club to be back where it once was. Which is very gracious, all things considered. Extremely. Especially since those executives made things incredibly complicated from the moment they walked through the door. When INEOS came in, the structure shifted radically, but it shifted into a total vacuum. Yeah, he describes this bluntly. Yeah, he does. He says, quote, the takeover process brought a lot of noise, uncertainty with the people, and disruptions. And then he follows that with a massive understatement. Oh yeah. He says, quote, so that was for the manager, for the coach. It was difficult to work. That’s clear. It was very complicated. Very complicated is his polite Dutch corporate speak for, well, it was an absolute administrative nightmare.
5:01 Basically, yeah. You have to look at the mechanics of the INEOS takeover. They brought in Omar Berrada as CEO, Dan Ashworth, Jason Wilcox, but because they were poached from rival clubs, they were all placed on gardening leave. Meaning they couldn’t legally work for United for months. Exactly. This created a massive gaping leadership vacuum right when the club needed total clarity. Which left Ten Hag utterly exposed, standing alone in front of the media firing squad twice a week. He talks about this saying, quote, there was a lot of speculation in the last two months. And he had to face that music alone. Right. He adds, quote, every week articles came out about it. I could deal very well with it, but obviously we had our problems. And his defence mechanism against this vacuum was just incredible, almost stubborn self-belief. Truly. He says, quote, I was thinking I’m the best manager for United, so it doesn’t make sense to dive in. That takes a very specific, almost monastic type of psychological armour, you know, to completely ignore the deafening noise of the British press. And just focus on the pitch. He literally says, quote, I was just focusing on my team. We had one chance to win a trophy, the FA Cup, and that’s immense. So that’s what we did. And we all know the history. They pulled off a tactical masterclass and beat City. They did. He describes the aftermath beautifully saying, quote, the celebrations on the pitch, let’s say they were the best moment in my Manchester life.
6:29 Because in that specific moment on the Wembley turf, he truly believed he had vindicated his methods against all odds. Right. Two trophies in two years. And that unexpected victory forced INEOS into an incredibly awkward public U-turn. They flew out to his holiday villa in Ibiza to trigger his contract extension. Ah, right. The infamous Ibiza Pact. This is where the story shifts from a triumphant underdog narrative into, well, a boardroom tragedy. So they fly to him and Ten Hag feels empowered. He says, quote, I wouldn’t go on with only one year left. He had leverage for once. And then he details the exact agreement, quote, so I said I need an extra year and we have to do it together. They promised me loyalty, they promised me backing, they promised communication that we get aligned. That alignment is key. Right. He finishes by saying, quote, we spoke about the issues but the promises they didn’t keep.
7:27 But the promises they didn’t keep. That might just be the defining epitaph of his entire era. Honestly, it sums it all up. It highlights the extreme danger of what we call conditional alignment in the corporate world, when leaders agree to a shared vision in the boardroom, but abandon it the second they face operational pressure. And we have to talk about this specific, massive promise they broke because it centres around Scott McTominay. Ten Hag states quote that’s why I got disappointed. And he elaborates on that exact conversation on the island. He does. He says quote in Ibiza we agreed. I said no selling Scott McTominay. We would go aligned in the transfer window. Which is a very clear boundary. Very clear. He goes on, quote, I make an argument, a reason. We don’t have scoring abilities.
8:12 Scott brings scoring abilities and great mentality. He has united in all his veins. And then they just ignored him. Completely. He says, quote, so when they bring up the subject, no. And in the end, they sold him. I got, of course, very embarrassed and disappointed. If we really drill down into the mechanics of this, selling a homegrown academy player like McTominay against the manager’s explicit wishes completely detonated Ten Hag’s authority. Oh, absolutely. Players are incredibly perceptive when they see a beloved dressing room leader sold off to balance the profitability and sustainability spreadsheets, it shows the squad that the manager isn’t actually the one driving the bus. And the British fan community completely recognise the depth of this betrayal.
8:58 One user on Reddit brought up the club’s long history of broken promises regarding ambition. It’s a pattern with United. It is. Another user expressed deep sympathy for Bruno Fernandes saying he was being constantly let down by the board. And another user pointed out the complete misalignment at the board level regarding team direction. And they were furious about the McTominay deal specifically. Furious. One user explicitly called INEOS out for lying to the coach about McTominay, literally calling them, quote, snakes. It’s an emotive harsh word, but from a change management perspective, if you tell your lead executive one thing to secure their commitment and then immediately do the opposite, you permanently destroy trust.
9:46 Right. There’s no coming back. Another user noted that the McTominay promise essentially proved that the board will just tell the coach what he wants to hear and then do the exact opposite. And what did they actually gain from it? Well, one user came back a second time to call the McTominay sale for Ugarte the most egregious transfer ever. And another joked bleakly that if keeping McTominay was the only actual win Ten Hag got from Ibiza, the bar is underground. Which is classic dark fan humour. Yeah, but it perfectly illustrates the absurdity. But despite this friction, Ten Hag fiercely defends his final few months. By October 2024, United were sitting 14th in the league table. 14th. A historic low. Right.
10:32 Yet he says, quote, I think it was quite weird to separate ways in that moment. And then he offers this heavily debated defence. Quote, all the data was showing, we are good. Okay, two poor games to Liverpool and Spurs. We were starting the process, let it progress. The gameplay is getting better. Ah, the data defence. This is the ultimate flash point where modern football analytics violently clash with traditional football realities. Okay, here is where I have to jump in and really push back on Ten Hag’s framing here. Wait a second. He is complaining about being sacked when United were 14th in the league claiming the quote, data was showing we are good. Yeah, I know where you’re going with this. Can you explain to me how a manager at the biggest club in England can realistically point to underlying metrics to save his job when the only data the punters care about is the points on the board? That is the multi-million dollar question, and it exposes the isolation of the modern manager.
11:28 Ten Hag is fundamentally an ideologue. He really is. He is looking at the process underneath the hood. If the underlying metrics like expected goals against or high turnovers won are trending upward, he genuinely believes the results will inevitably follow. But Old Trafford isn’t a spreadsheet. Exactly. You’re entirely right to push back. It is a highly emotional reactive theatre. When you are hammered three-nil at home by Liverpool and Tottenham, the data is entirely irrelevant. The visual evidence of the team collapsing completely overrides any analytical model. And deep down, he basically admits he knew the axe was falling. He says, quote, maybe they can say differently, but I see on the pitch. And every game they fought. He felt the players were still trying. Yeah. He adds, quote, also my last game that was probably one of our best games, we should have won against West Ham.
12:17 But I’m sure the process was already ongoing. There were already people, maybe even in the team, who knew what would happen the day after Maybe even in the team that is a staggering implication of internal leaking and betrayal He noticed the subtle shifts of behaviour earlier that week in Turkey. He says quote I can read situations I see when people are not in Istanbul all of a sudden something is going on He knew they were holding meetings behind his back right Right. And he adds with real grievance, quote, but still after that summer where you get apologies for their behaviour and that we would go to build, it’s surprising. Think about that. INEOS literally apologised to him for interviewing other managers, promised a cultural reset, and then within weeks, the shadow games began again.
13:04 Brutal. And he genuinely believed he was on the verge of European glory. We targeted the Europa League and I think when you choose a manager and he proves the last two seasons winning trophies getting into finals then I don’t think it’s good club management to change. And then he added, I did watch the final, but everything was changed. That must have been incredibly bitter to watch Ruben Amorim lead the team out. Yet he insists his ego isn’t the issue. He says, quote, I don’t have that ego, but I have the confidence. He wanted basic transparency. Exactly. He says, quote, it’s not about me, it is about the club. I can accept that new leadership is coming in and they want to appoint their own people, but just tell me. That’s a foundational tenet of healthy human resources that was glaringly absent. And the disconnect started from day one with Ratcliffe. Ten Hag recalls, quote, but after the first meeting, he started talking about the structure in the football club, how the manager should be head coach.
14:11 Stripping away his power immediately. Right. To which Ten Hag replied, quote, I said, OK, let’s discuss, but my contract is different. I never heard anything. Ghosted by a billionaire. Literally. And the media rushed in. Ten Hag says, quote, then every press conference, they ask me if the structure should be changed. I always want to cooperate in a club. You can’t do this on your own. You need a strategy. He says exactly that, quote, you need to find a strategy about philosophy, game model, about team profile, individual profiles. That is what I was used to, but with them, there was no communication. He is confirming that Manchester United simply had no alignment. He summarises it perfectly. Quote, the leadership, you need their competence, you need the right strategy.
14:56 And asks the existential questions. Yes. Quote, what is your identity? What are the work methods? You need the right structures and quality people, then you need time. Time. The rarest commodity in modern football. Which brings us to the current guy, Michael Carrick. Ten Hag actually defends his former assistant. He says, quote, it is not the solution to dismiss him. One hundred percent not. A rare moment of solidarity. He explains why the pressure is building. Quote, fans will demand this if results don’t improve. It is coming out from the stomach, from the emotion. You have to make rational decisions. He’s pleading for patience. Yeah, it’s, quote, he showed good coaching abilities at Middlesbrough and last season, so let him do his process. I think he has a good staff.
15:43 He’s framing Carrick’s struggles as a symptom of the club’s systemic impatience. But the fans are divided. One user expressed a genuine fear that Carrick is getting the exact same treatment as Ten Hag. But not everyone agrees. No. Another user flat-out disagreed with Ten Hag on Carrick, noting the actual football is quote putrid. Which encapsulates the fan duality. Yeah. You can recognise a broken board while seeing unwatchable football. Exactly. One user argued a new manager couldn’t improve the current squad anyway, while another cynically noted that managers never advocate for other managers to be sacked. A fair cynical observation of the managerial union. But the broader blame falls on executives. One user validated Ten Hag’s point that there was no financial insight or recruitment plan. Another summarised the repeat cycle of managers being sold ideas but never supported.
16:43 A rinse and repeat cycle of corporate self-sabotage. Even journalist Laurie Whitwell chimed in, blaming the Glazers’ distant yet hands-on approach. One user blamed management uncertainty for the rot culture. And looking back, fans have regrets. Oh yeah. One user regretted admitting United made the right choice in appointing Carrick over Ole Gunnar Solskjaer. Another questioned firing Rangnick who could have provided stability. And another user placed absolute blame on directors and owners over the past several years? Pointing the finger directly at the disease. So Ten Hag is now far from that disease. He says of Twente, quote, in the region, it’s very, very big.
17:30 And adds quote, and this is a big club for the Netherlands, not global, very clear. But there’s always pressure as well. People are quite critical here. So things have to work. Meaning at United, things simply didn’t work. Exactly. Let’s pivot to Section 2, From how Ten Hag was managed to who he managed, the tactical mandate and the transfer tug of war. This is where the narrative gets incredibly messy. Ten Hag had a clear mandate. He says, quote, So our identity should be dynamic, attacking football, counter-press. And that is what Richard and John demanded me to do. The famous Ajax blueprint. He continues, quote, Play possession in the opponent’s half. Of course they want to win. Old Trafford is the theater of dreams. They want adventure football.
18:17 You then need the profiles. That is the crux of every transfer argument. You can’t play a high line without fast defenders. He spells out what he asked for. Quote, for me, you need the ball playing centre back and you need a ball winning centre half. Also able to play on a high line. And he laid it out in his first season. Yep. Quote, I said for the first season, centre half, there is a problem. Centre midfield, there is a problem. And especially I need a strategist. Then we need goals. And the goals were always the issue. He admits it. Quote, and that was the biggest issue in all my three years. Goals. But to get those players, he made hardcore demands. He did. He says, quote, I set requirements in advance about how I want to work. And famously added, quote, if they aren’t granted, I won’t do it. I am ultimately responsible and accountable for the results. I don’t want to be the sole ruler. I stand for cooperation, but control in transfers is a condition for me. Let’s pause right here. He explicitly demanded control over transfers as a strict condition. It’s the absolute lightning rod, because fans look at Antony, Onana, Mount, catastrophic overspending.
19:29 But Ten Hag distances himself from the money. He says, quote, everyone’s thinking the manager is doing negotiations that I’m involved in financial issues. But I was never. He is drawing a hard line between identifying a target and negotiating the fee. Let me play devil’s advocate for the fans here, because this is a massive contradiction. Go for it. He explicitly says he wasn’t involved in financial issues. But he also admits he demanded control over transfers as a condition. How can a manager force the club to spend nearly 100 million pounds on Antony, a player tied to his own Dutch network, and then wash his hands of the financial consequences. It is the ultimate paradox. You hit the nail on the head. He wants the supreme power to pick players, but zero accountability when the financial implications ruin the budget.
20:16 You can’t just shrug and say you didn’t sign the cheque. Exactly, especially with amortisation. When you pay $95 million for Antony on a five-year deal, that cost is spread out at nearly $20 million a year on the PSR books. When he flops, you can’t sell him. It locks up financial flexibility for half a decade. And the Reddit community was ruthless on this. One user pointed out Ten Hag’s agent Kees Vos had wide influence, resulting in the Antony and Onana masterpieces, as they sarcastically called them. The SEG agency connection is a huge, uncomfortable subtext. Another user believed Ten Hag’s damaging transfers set the club back years. Another user fiercely refused to accept any revisionism, stating ETH’s transfers, quote, f****d us up. The anger is visceral because those contracts are still weighing the club down. One user laughed at Ten Hag claiming he had no recruitment plan when he literally had veto power. Another blamed Ten Hag for pushing signings from his own agency, SEG, and playing the Donut Formation long ball. Ah, the Donut Formation. Ten Hag wanted to press high, but his defenders lacked pace. So forwards pushed up, defenders dropped deep, leaving a massive 40 yard hole in the midfield, a donut.
21:31 One user condemned the untold damage Ten Hag did with transfers. But some fans aimed higher. Another blamed Murtough for paying $95 million for Antony, making the Kane transfer financially impossible. The club’s incompetence crippled their own manager’s ultimate desires. Another complained about the absolute s**t bought from his agency. But to be fair, one user pushed back on the SEG narrative, pointing out only Hojlund and Amrabat worked with SEG. It’s important to separate fact from hysteria, but the optics were terrible. So let’s look at the targets he really wanted. First, Frenkie de Jong. Ten Hag says, quote, of course I did my best. I set up meetings with him where it was Richard and John involved as well to persuade him to come over.
22:21 A painful public pursuit. He adds, quote, he could have been very important building the team, not only that year, but for the future. But we didn’t make it. Because the player simply didn’t want to leave Barcelona. Then there was Declan Rice. Ten Hag says, quote, the issue was that West Ham didn’t want to let him go. I think we could have done more to test. He went to Arsenal instead. Right. Ten Hag adds, quote, we were on one page. They tried, but I don’t know how the process went. The point is at United, you need outstanding players. And then the ultimate white whale. Ten Hag famously says, quote, I want only one player and you know who. Harry Kane. Exactly. He explains why, quote, I think a club like United, you need these profiles to be successful.
23:07 Personality and they are mature and they’re accountable. That word again, accountable. He felt the young players weren’t ready. Quote, we signed five, six players, young, high potentials, but they are not the finished product. They need guidance from good professionals like Kane, Rice and Bruno. He wanted prime age leaders. He even tried to bring in Danny Welbeck. He confirms, quote, for sure we were in contact, and clarifies, quote, not me, often Darren. And he was very interested. Welbeck would have been a great mature presence. He also tried for Brian Brobbey. Quote, at first not everyone was aligned. A classic United transfer story. Yep. He says, quote, then we convinced him, but then we were late and already he was in a different process. Just too slow.
23:53 The fans had plenty to say. One user laughed at how the subreddit once thought missing out on Rice was the right call. Another argued the first season’s success was just Ole squad plus a world-class DM and it fell apart as ETH bought his own players. A devastating critique. Another user pointed out Kane and Rice chose objectively better clubs, Bayern and Arsenal, so it wasn’t the board’s fault. But another user rebutted that Kane and Rice avoided United because of the board’s incompetence. A self-fulfilling prophecy of failure. One user pointed to the De Jong saga as proof Kane wasn’t the only one player he wanted. Another called out Ten Hag’s zero accountability for Antony and Onana.
24:40 The fans haven’t forgotten. One user highlighted the hypocrisy of keeping Ugarte while selling McTominay against Ten Hag’s wishes. Another wished the journalist pressed Ten Hag harder on agency signings. And another user reminded everyone how Ten Hag ousted De Gea to waste half a billion on a d*****t list of players. So if the transfers were a mess, the dressing room was a war zone. Exactly. Section 3. The toxic culture and player power. Ten Hag explicitly blames the executives, quote, and so they are continuing the toxic culture. They fuel it. They give the power to the players. Outright accusing them of undermining him. Take Marcus Rashford. Ten Hag says, quote, Rashford is an amazing player if his mindset is right.
25:30 I always showed my trust in him, played him. But when you show these standards, sometimes you have to make corrections. Referring to the disciplinary benchings. But the ultimate test was Cristiano Ronaldo. Ten Hag pulls no punches. Quote, he let the team down and he let me down because we planned with him. Shattering the narrative that he wanted Ronaldo gone from day one. He tried to connect. Quote, I flew out to Portugal to speak with him about what I was aiming for before I came to United. Obviously he’s one of the best in football history. I respected him a lot. But the reality on the pitch was different. Right. He adds, quote, but at that time, as a manager, I had to make a rational decision and keep the players I admire in. Based on tactical reality.
26:17 He states, quote, I confronted him with this. And explains, quote, many times I say, Ronnie, everyone wants to work for you to bring you in the right position. But if you can’t bring yourself in the box, you can’t score. He just refused to adapt. Ten Hag says, quote, he was not capable to do this. It’s the wrong idea to put this to me that I expected him to do the pressing, that he’s exhausted. But he couldn’t. He ran neither in possession nor out of possession. The reason was because he didn’t prepare himself. That is a devastating critique of a guy known for his obsessive preparation. If a forward refuses to run, playing a high pressing system is like playing with tin men. Ten Hag summarises, quote, every top team has to embrace the top player, but the top player has to work for the team.
27:05 But then comes the bombshell. The training ground sabotage. He was telling the players, save your legs at the training. I understand it when you were top fit. You have sessions, you can save the legs. But first you have to train yourself to get into the right fitness levels. Telling teammates not to run in training is textbook mutiny. Ten Hag zooms out saying, quote, players have to act. They have a big responsibility. Football is for some not the highest priority and United for some wasn’t the highest priority. Questioning their fundamental dedication. He names the faction. Quote, I can say I think that’s what the Madrid connection brought in. That players are powerful and they want to decide. Casemiro, Varane, Ronaldo.
27:50 Yeah. Quote, in my opinion, it didn’t suit the phase United was in. The leadership wanted attacking dynamic football and these players wanted to play what fitted themselves. They basically decided they knew better than the manager. He highlights Casemiro’s drop in form. Quote, then of course it looked like he got demotivated. I don’t know what they told him. Implying the board sold Casemiro a false bill of goods. And regarding Fred’s public criticisms of his man management, Ten Hag brushes it off. Quote, I’m not mad at Fred. He justifies the friction? Quote, you fight with your players when they are showing inefficient and unprepared standards. But it’s always with respect. You want to push them, you want to get the best out of them. Now before we dig into the fan reaction, we have to acknowledge the wider context.
28:38 Right. When reading the Reddit threads, some users brought up the highly publicised off-pitch legal accusations surrounding Ronaldo. We must state clearly that we are impartially reporting the fan discourse without taking a side or endorsing these allegations. Exactly. We are strictly looking at how the fan base processes his legacy, but ignoring it misrepresents our sources. Because it’s a massive reason why the fanbase is so intensely polarised about him. It’s essential context. Returning to football, one user asked Ten Hag, who let the team down after Ronaldo left, mocking him for acting like he won the Champions League without him.
29:27 A fair point. His departure didn’t fix everything. Another user called running off Ronaldo the best thing Ten Hag did, and another vividly remembered the 4-0 Brentford beating on Ronaldo’s return. That game proved you couldn’t play modern football with him. One user accused Ronaldo of spending his time waving his arms and ruining Solskjaer’s stint. Another stated Ronaldo made the team worse and his goals didn’t cover for his tantrums and toxicity. The individual succeeding at the expense of the collective. Another credited Rangnick and Ole for at least knowing how to minimise Ronaldo’s declining defensive work rate. One user called Ronaldo […]. Strong words but reflective of the exhaustion fans felt. Another found it depressing that someone so committed to healthy living is so lacking in self-awareness.
30:26 One user found it fascinating that Ronaldo downed tools and influenced others to do so. It really is wild. Another called it disgraceful if he undermined training. A third stated it’s hardly surprising given his recent years. One user noted Casemiro and Varane didn’t like Ten Hag either, but remain professional, unlike Ronaldo, who viewed the manager as beneath him. Basic workplace respect was missing. But some didn’t buy it. One user struggled to believe Ronaldo actually told players to save their legs. And another echoed that disbelief, wondering how the first to arrive guy told players not to train. It highlights the unreliability of narrators in a bitter divorce. I wanted to throw one original analogy at you to challenge Ten Hag’s man management.
31:14 Let’s hear it. If you’re a conductor and your lead violinist refuses to play the sheet music, you don’t just complain they’re ruining the orchestra. You figure out how to manage their ego. Did Ten Hag fail to realise that managing Manchester United is 20% tactics and 80% managing massive, fragile egos? That is the core tragedy of his tenure. You are absolutely right, Sir Alex Ferguson was an unparalleled manager of men. Ten Hag treated Old Trafford like an Ajax laboratory where players were just data points expected to perfectly execute an algorithm. When the human element corrupted the algorithm, he just kept yelling at the computer. Well said. So what does this all mean for you? Let’s synthesise this. You now have the complete picture.
32:00 A manager squeezed relentlessly between a chaotic, promise-breaking boardroom and a dressing room clinging to outdated power dynamics, all while making deeply flawed transfer decisions himself. It’s a masterclass in massive corporate dysfunction, failed change management, and the lethal danger of conditional alignment. Exactly. This isn’t just football. This happens in major corporations every day. Absolutely. Which leaves us with a final provocative thought for you to mull over. Consider the paradox of modern mega clubs. Managers are hired to build long-term dynasties and install deep philosophies, but the financial realities in media ecosystems demand immediate short-term fixes.
32:45 Is Manchester United uniquely unmanageable? Or are they just the loudest, most expensive example of a fundamentally broken industry where the role of the traditional manager is completely obsolete? That’s a brilliant question. Can any single human being actually manage the modern Manchester United? That is the multi-million dollar question. Thank you for joining us for this deep dive into the Ten Hag files. Catch you on the next deep dive.
This transcript was made with Whisper speech recognition, with names checked against the show notes. The hosts are AI voices, and their words are kept as spoken; anything they got wrong is corrected in a dated note on this page.
Sources
- Sky Sports (republished from The Athletic): Erik ten Hag interview: Man Utd’s broken ‘promises’, wanting Kane, Ronaldo tension, FA Cup glory, by Laurie Whitwell (20 October 2026)
- Heart (republished from The Athletic): Erik ten Hag interview (20 October 2026)
- Sky Sports: Antony: Manchester United sign Brazil winger from Ajax for £86m (1 September 2022)
- ITV News: US judge dismisses Cristiano Ronaldo rape lawsuit (11 June 2022)
- Manchester United: Club statement on Michael Carrick (12 November 2026)
- Fan reaction: r/reddevils and Manchester United fan forums
Fact-checked by Ram Gohil on 19 November 2026.
